Page 128 of 144
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: Oct 19th, '15, 12:26
by Ziaheart
There were Wild Knuffel with themes before where there were obvious pairs (like black swan and swan princess ones and Hansel and Gretel ones). So if your three Wilds were truly distinct from each other and not just recolours of exact same Wild with minimal costume changes then I think it should be allowed.
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: Nov 2nd, '15, 15:08
by AlkseeyaKC
If I made the hands like the base of the knuffel and had the one ear fliped over like on the other stages, would that work?
Also wanted to pont out, I have two accepted knuffel that fallow the same flow.
Also would showing the stages help? I just wanted it hide them to make if fun for all the people that love my other neon knuffel.
Edit:
Spoiler: Maybe this?
And show all the stages. as in no hiding them.
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: Nov 2nd, '15, 19:02
by Firn
Yes, allowing people to see the stages before adopting would help. It's still not what I consider a proper evolution, but since we hardly get any new Wild Knuffel lately I have been pretty loose with the rules. (The Knuffel is also too big to fit into the box for proportion, but I don't even argue about that anymore. It's peoples their own fault if the Knuffels head is not located on the proper spot in the signature images, I guess and if people adopting the Knuffel don't mind, it's none of my concern) I just don't want people to adopt something that will look completely different in the second stage, without them being able to see it before.
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: Nov 9th, '15, 20:31
by Micamone
okay. so you say the knuffel has to fill out it's area with an equal margin, but then you say it's the base that actually has to do that and its evolution with extras like wings and hats can actually go to the edges.
so I'm a bit confused here. I thought, because of your first line in the "proportions" post, that the entire knuffel has to fill out the entire image proportionally. But is that not so? If the finished knuffel is off-centered for the sake of the base being where it is supposed to be, is that okay?
for example, say one draws a wild knuffel with a final stage of it wearing a hat that goes right up to the top of the image, but no platform shoes or high heels that go to the bottom (so it is now off-center as a finished project).
or, someone has a chibi base that faces left or right, but still fills out the "base zone" as it should. Then later in it's final stages, it gets a long dress or skirt that trails behind them. This makes the left and right margins of the final knuffel uneven.
Are these examples both okay? because even though the finished knuffel has an uneven margin (but follows all the other rules), the base is what matters?
because the letter I got about my wild knuffel says it's off center, but I know I tried hard to get it centered as a final image. If the base is centered where it should be, then the wings will be close to the edge on one side but not the other...
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: Nov 10th, '15, 15:13
by Firn
The base is what needs to be in center. The final Knuffel with all elements like hats or dresses does not need to be in center. This is because the Knuffel signature images show the face of the Knuffel and always take the same position for this. If your base is not centered, it will not be positioned properly.
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: Nov 10th, '15, 23:07
by Micamone
Great, thank you! Sorry my questions are long-winded, but I wanted to be totally sure.
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: Nov 22nd, '15, 01:13
by LilChaosKitten
Firn... I just wanted to ask a quick question... >.>;;
For Halloween Next Year, I am working on
a LARGE GROUP OF MONSTER GIRLS...
( Approx. 20? :X )
I wanted to know how you would like
me to submit them Next Sept/October?
( I don't want to overwhelm you or
Starkad... and I would like to submit them
all for The Halloween season Next Year... )
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: Nov 23rd, '15, 10:30
by Firn
Huh? I don't really care how you do it, it's not more or less work for me either way - Submit them all at once or one each day, howere it pleases you. 
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: Nov 24th, '15, 05:18
by LilChaosKitten
Kk. <3
Just wanted to make sure,
lovely lady. :3 <3
Re: Why was my Wild Knuffel rejected?
Posted: Nov 25th, '15, 11:04
by L0VE
Eek I had a rejected Knuffel OTL
It was only after re-reading this thread I realized it sent in my entry too soon and hoped for the best, but alas still rejected q uq!!
I feel silly for working so hard on it before checking again aha. Oh well, time to work on another one! o3o!!
EDIT does this look opkay so far for a base??
link
