Well, I was rejected due to different sizes, clothes changing, and having different hairs. :s I'm writing this here since I can't reply to the rejection message I got.
http://i220.photobucket.com/albums/dd12/onisukka/Knuffels/deri1_onispng.png
http://i220.photobucket.com/albums/dd12/onisukka/Knuffels/deri2_onis.png
http://i220.photobucket.com/albums/dd12/onisukka/Knuffels/deri3_onis.png
http://i220.photobucket.com/albums/dd12/onisukka/Knuffels/deri4_onis.png
http://i220.photobucket.com/albums/dd12/onisukka/Knuffels/deri5_onis.png


Please change the description/rules that you have set.
- There is no mention that the knuffel should have the same proportions (in pixels) in every stage. In this case the knuffel's evolution is slow, thus she ages at the same time and her proportions change. If aging is not allowed, please write that in the rules.
- There was nothing said about knuffels not being able to grow/cut their hair, and it was said that the clothes should evolve, which mine does. It changes color and is cut/grown/changes places, the overall design is the same. Same with the decoration, I don't see why the knuffel couldn't decide to change it's place.
- The spots imply that the skin is changing colors (in a spot-like manner), ie. evolving from light skin to darker skin, then finally settling to lighter gray (and being left with few marks in the face of the skin color change). Same with the eyes. Please elaborate in the rules that skin is supposed to change color in particular manner.

I'm okay with the decisions made, although slightly disappointed after going through all the trouble to draw those... but I at least think they should be written in the rules.

I don't really associate growth with aging. Also, we have wild knuffels that age/change proportions, ie. Grimask and dustbunny. The "no growth" -rule is also written in the explanation of evolution, and it's kinda hazy if it denies it or not, I read it as that growth doesn't count as evolution.
ie. Jabberwocky hatches from an egg, which was denied in the same section?

Grimask, dustbunny, jabberwocky;
viewtopic.php?p=5837879#p5837879

How is it evolution, if it first grows hair and then they disappear? Sure, they are few examples of regressive evolution in history of Earth, but knuffel are rather supposed to go with regular evolution scheme ^^'

umm. The whole point of evolution is to change things more fitting to your surrounding. We evolved from monkeys, we don't have tails anymore.

The hair doesn't just "disappear". :x She cuts her back hair, thus is left with different kind of haircut than in the beginning - and more complex, cleaner and better than the ones in middle, more fitting the her style.
http://i220.photobucket.com/albums/dd12 ... nispng.png
http://i220.photobucket.com/albums/dd12 ... 5_onis.png

But you said it was rejected due to size, clothes and hair...?

The skin was mentioned as being one of the reasons too.

Honestly, evolution in clothes is hardly seen. She looks like she's wearing totally different dress in 1-3, 4 and 5.

The 'scarf' is brought down and part of it is cut into a belt. In the 5th, she puts the scarf to rest on her arms, making a better design that fits her style. It changes, becomes more fitting to her aging.

You know, you can always fix her and resubmit?

Maybe I will, but I'm not really writing this so that the knuffel could be accepted without extra work. That doesn't remove the problem, which is that I read all the rules, checked all the official and wild knuffels, and did my decisions about the changes based on those.

I'm not saying that you're wrong or that you should accept my knuffel, I'm merely pointing out that the rules are not clear enough to express what you want from knuffels. Am I wrong to not want someone else to do work just so that they will be declined?

http://i42.tinypic.com/wafxx5.jpg
http://i39.tinypic.com/b9boqv.jpg
These are not the same proportions. I'd say the bunny is growing, rather than evolving (it starts off a small thing, and then becomes bigger, a.k.a. ages).

http://i41.tinypic.com/4fuauh.jpg
http://i43.tinypic.com/xd5wyp.jpg
The head and the hands are smaller in the latter picture, and I'd find it weird to claim that they are of the same age.
I'm not sure how else to interpret the jabby's pictures, other than saying that he's hatching and growing.

If you don't want regression, write it in the rules?

Again, even if cutting hair is not evolution, it is not denied in the rules.
Her dress does get longer and change color, which should be evolution regarding to pictures of other knuffels. If cutting cloth is not allowed, write it in the rules.

edit;
ml1201: If that was meant for me, thank you for taking the time to note me about this, but I have read that post before too. Firn talks about glow, clear-cut and furniture in that post and she writes "I will actually enforce this rule strictly", not that she will enforce all the rules.